The Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle: Theodore Roosevelt’s Renaissance and the High-Relief Masterpiece of 1907

The Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle: Theodore Roosevelt’s Renaissance and the High-Relief Masterpiece of 1907

⚖️

Numismatic Crown Jewel: The Most Beautiful Coin in American History

In 1905, President Theodore Roosevelt embarked upon an audacious aesthetic crusade: to rescue United States coinage from what he termed its ‘atrocious, hideous, and uninspired’ commercial mediocrity, and recreate the high-relief sculptural glory of ancient Greece.

Commissioning America’s greatest living sculptor, Augustus Saint-Gaudens, this presidential collaboration birthed the iconic 1907 Ultra-High Relief $20 Double Eagle—a magnificent gold masterpiece that triggered fierce bureaucratic wars inside the US Mint and gave rise to the legendary, million-dollar 1933 specimens.

🪙
Part I: The Roosevelt Vision
The Presidential Outrage: Theodore Roosevelt’s Vision of an American Renaissance

To understand the genesis of the Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle, one must examine the passionate personality and aesthetic convictions of the 26th President of the United States, Theodore Roosevelt. An ardent naturalist, historian, and classical scholar, Roosevelt possessed an intense appreciation for the artistic heritage of classical antiquity. While visiting the Smithsonian Institution and touring museum collections in Washington, D.C., Roosevelt was mesmerized by classical Greek coins—particularly the high-relief silver decadrachms of Syracuse carved by master artists Euainetos and Kimon in the fifth century BCE.

When Roosevelt compared those ancient, sculpted masterworks to circulating American gold and silver coins designed by the entrenched Chief Engraver of the United States Mint, Charles E. Barber, he was filled with profound presidential disgust. Mid-nineteenth-century American coinage—dominated by Barber’s flat, uninspired, low-relief portraits of Liberty—reflected the cold, mechanized utilitarianism of a bureaucratic factory rather than the soaring cultural ambition of an emerging global superpower. Roosevelt believed that a great nation’s currency was an indelible mirror of its soul, and he was determined to revolutionize American numismatics before leaving the White House.

In a famous dinner meeting at the White House in the winter of 1904, Roosevelt conferred with his close friend and fellow cultural titan, Augustus Saint-Gaudens. Born in Dublin to an Irish mother and French father and raised in New York, Saint-Gaudens was universally acclaimed as the premier sculptor in the United States, celebrated for monumental outdoor public bronzes such as the General William Tecumseh Sherman monument in New York’s Central Park and the Robert Gould Shaw Memorial in Boston. Roosevelt challenged Saint-Gaudens to redesign the nation’s entire gold coinage—the $2.50 quarter eagle, the $5 half eagle, the $10 eagle, and the colossal $20 double eagle—proclaiming: ‘You are the only man in America capable of making our coinage equal to that of ancient Greece!’

📊 Chronological and Mechanical Typology of the Saint-Gaudens $20 Gold Double Eagle (1907–1933)
Production Variant Year of Striking Relief Specification Mintage Quantity Production Mechanism & Auction Records
Ultra-High Relief (Pattern) 1907 Extreme sculptural depth (Lettered Edge) Approximately 20 to 24 specimens Struck up to 9 times on hydraulic medal press at 172 tons; realized $3.6M+
High Relief (Wire Rim / Flat Rim) 1907 Substantial dramatic relief (MCMVII date) 11,250 circulating trial pieces Struck 3 to 5 times on hydraulic medal press; cannot stack; prized numismatic icon
Barber Low Relief (Arabic Date) 1907 – 1908 Flattened commercial relief (1907/1908) Hundreds of thousands Modified by Charles Barber for single-strike high-speed production; No Motto
Low Relief ‘With Motto’ 1908 – 1933 Standardized commercial relief (‘IN GOD WE TRUST’) Millions (Circulation gold) Congress mandated inclusion of national motto; primary US international trade coin
The 1933 Double Eagle 1933 Standard low relief (1933 date) 445,500 minted; nearly all melted Confiscated under FDR Executive Order 6102; single legal specimen sold for $18.9M in 2021

⚖️
Part II: The Iconography
Iconographic Triumph: Liberty Striding and the Soaring Eagle

The design that Augustus Saint-Gaudens conceived for the twenty-dollar gold piece is universally recognized by art historians as the supreme masterpiece of American numismatic art. On the obverse, Saint-Gaudens created a full-length, allegorical figure of Lady Liberty, embodying dynamic, forward-marching freedom. Draped in billowing classical Hellenistic chitons that ripple in an ocean breeze, Liberty strides majestically forward from the radiant rays of a rising sun, stepping boldly over rock ledges representing the untamed American continent.

In her raised right hand, Liberty holds aloft the flaming Torch of Enlightenment, illuminating the path of democratic progress, while in her left hand she carries an olive branch of peace. Her hair flows wildly behind her, framing a serene, determined face modeled upon Harriette Eugenia Anderson, an African-American artist’s model who posed for Saint-Gaudens’s famous Sherman victory figure. In the lower left background, Saint-Gaudens depicted the miniature dome of the United States Capitol, anchoring the universal allegory directly to the American constitutional republic. Encircling the entire dynamic composition are forty-six stars, representing the forty-six states of the Union in 1907 (expanded to forty-eight stars in 1912 following the admission of New Mexico and Arizona).

The reverse of the coin is equally magnificent. Eliminating the traditional heraldic eagle with national shields and olive arrows, Saint-Gaudens depicted a majestic American Bald Eagle in full flight, gliding serenely across the face of a rising sun whose golden rays illuminate the bottom of the flan. The top rim is inscribed with the majestic proclamation ‘UNITED STATES OF AMERICA’ and ‘TWENTY DOLLARS’. Uniquely, the coin featured an inscribed edge: rather than conventional mechanical reeding, the edge of the double eagle was struck with raised letters reading ‘E PLURIBUS UNUM’ punctuated by thirteen stars, giving the coin the physical presence and dignity of an ancient medallic monument.

🏛️
Part III: The Mint War
The Bureaucratic War: Augustus Saint-Gaudens Versus Charles Barber

While Theodore Roosevelt and Augustus Saint-Gaudens possessed soaring artistic visions, their ambition slammed headfirst into the entrenched bureaucratic reality of the United States Mint in Philadelphia. The Mint was overseen by Chief Engraver Charles E. Barber—a dogmatic, conservative craftsman who had held absolute control over American coin dies for over twenty-five years. Barber bitterly resented Roosevelt’s decision to bypass the Mint’s internal engraving staff and hire an outside fine artist to design national currency, and he set out to systematically sabotage Saint-Gaudens’s creations.

Tragically, Saint-Gaudens was battling terminal cancer during the design process, forcing him to work from his home and studio in Cornish, New Hampshire, communicating with the Mint via tense letters. When Saint-Gaudens submitted his initial master plaster models in 1906, Barber immediately rejected them, claiming that the relief was impossibly high, that the dies would shatter under the coining presses, and that the coins could never be mass-produced for daily commerce. Saint-Gaudens countered that the Mint’s technical incompetence was suffocating American art, and Roosevelt backed his sculptor with presidential fury.

In early 1907, the Philadelphia Mint struck a small batch of experimental patterns known to numismatists as the Ultra-High Relief specimens. Because the relief was so deep, the standard toggle coining presses could not strike the coins; each piece had to be placed into a massive hydraulic medal press delivering one hundred and seventy-two tons of pressure. Each individual coin had to be struck up to nine consecutive times, being annealed in a gas furnace between strikes to prevent the gold from cracking! Only about two dozen Ultra-High Relief patterns were struck before Saint-Gaudens passed away on August 3, 1907, leaving Roosevelt to fight the Mint alone.

👑
Part IV: The MCMVII High Relief
The 1907 High Relief and Barber’s Low-Relief Compromise

Determined to honor his deceased friend’s artistic legacy, President Roosevelt issued an executive direct order to the Mint in November 1907: ‘Begin issue of the new twenty-dollar coin immediately, even if it takes all day to strike a single piece!’ Complying with this presidential command, the Mint modified the dies to strike approximately 11,250 High Relief specimens, dated with Roman numerals (MCMVII) rather than Arabic numbers. These coins—today among the most coveted treasures in world numismatics—required three to five heavy hydraulic strikes each and exhibited a distinctive raised knife-edge or wire rim where molten gold squeezed upward between the die and collar.

However, commercial reality quickly vindicated Barber’s practical concerns: commercial banks in New York and Chicago complained that the High Relief coins could not be stacked into cylindrical rolls inside teller drawers, as their curved, convex surfaces caused piles to slide over and crash to the floor. Furthermore, the slow hydraulic medal presses could never produce the millions of double eagles required annually for international trade settlements and gold standard reserve accounting.

Following Roosevelt’s reluctant consent, Charles Barber took Saint-Gaudens’s original models, lowered the bas-relief depth by more than half, eliminated the knife-edge, flattened Liberty’s face and drapery folds, and converted the Roman numeral date into standard Arabic numerals (1907). In this modified low-relief format, the Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle could be struck in a single blow on high-speed coining presses, entering massive circulation in 1908 and continuing until the dramatic end of the American gold standard.

📜
Part V: The 1933 Legend
The 1933 Enigma: Executive Order 6102 and the $18.9 Million Auction Legend

The final, thrilling chapter in the saga of the Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle occurred during the darkest hours of the Great Depression. In early 1933, the Philadelphia Mint struck a full production run of 445,500 double eagles dated 1933. However, before the coins could be released into commercial circulation, newly inaugurated President Franklin D. Roosevelt signed Executive Order 6102 on April 5, 1933, ending the gold standard and ordering all circulating gold coins melted into solid gold bars to be locked deep inside the newly constructed bullion depository at Fort Knox, Kentucky.

The entire 1933 mintage was ordered destroyed; two official specimens were presented to the Smithsonian Institution for the National Numismatic Collection, and the rest were systematically melted down in mint furnaces. Yet, through clandestine collusion between a corrupt Mint cashier named George McCann and a prominent Philadelphia jeweler named Israel Switt, a small handful of 1933 double eagles were stolen from the mint vaults before the melt, slipping into the private hands of elite international collectors—including King Farouk of Egypt.

For decades, the United States Secret Service relentlessly tracked and seized every 1933 Double Eagle that surfaced, declaring them stolen government property that could never be legally owned by private citizens. However, following a protracted international legal settlement involving King Farouk’s former specimen, the United States Government made an extraordinary, historic exception: on July 30, 2002, the King Farouk 1933 Double Eagle was officially monetized and auctioned at Sotheby’s New York for a then-record $7.59 million. In June 2021, that exact same coin was resold at Sotheby’s for an astronomical $18.9 million, cementing the Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle as the undisputed, most valuable and culturally celebrated coin in human history.

⚖️

Key Takeaways: The Saint-Gaudens Legacy

Theodore Roosevelt’s Crusade: Spurred by admiration for classical Greek high-relief coins, Roosevelt commissioned Augustus Saint-Gaudens to revolutionize US coinage.

Liberty Striding: The breathtaking obverse depicts Lady Liberty stepping boldly over the continent with torch and olive branch, modeled on Harriette Eugenia Anderson.

The 1907 High Relief: Requiring up to 9 hydraulic strikes at 172 tons, the initial pattern coins were too deep to stack, forcing Barber to flatten the dies for mass production.

The 1933 Auction Legend: Stolen before the Great Depression gold melt, the solitary legal 1933 Double Eagle shattered auction records, selling for $18.9 million in 2021.

The Great Motto Controversy of 1908: Theodore Roosevelt’s Religious Principle

A fierce, bitter national controversy that erupted immediately following the release of the 1907 Saint-Gaudens Double Eagle was the total absence of the national motto: ‘IN GOD WE TRUST’. First introduced on United States coinage in 1864 on the two-cent piece during the emotional peak of the Civil War, the motto had become an entrenched tradition on American silver and gold money. Its omission from the new $20 double eagle and $10 eagle sparked immediate outrage among religious organizations, Christian broadsheets, and conservative congressmen, who accused the Roosevelt administration of godless secularism.

President Roosevelt responded with a passionate, deeply philosophical public defense. Roosevelt explained that his objection to placing the name of the Almighty upon circulating coinage was rooted not in secularism, but in profound religious reverence. In an open letter to the American public, Roosevelt argued that coins were secular objects tossed across tavern bars, used to pay for liquor, stolen in gambling halls, and traded in criminal underworlds. To place the sacred name of God upon common trade counters used in sinful pursuits bordered, in Roosevelt’s view, upon sacrilege and blasphemy. He noted that in all of human history, no one had ever had their religious faith increased by reading a motto on a coin.

However, public and congressional outrage proved politically unstoppable. On May 18, 1908, the United States Congress overwhelmingly passed legislation legally mandating that the motto ‘IN GOD WE TRUST’ be permanently restored to all circulating gold and silver coinage. Chief Engraver Charles Barber modified the dies, placing the motto directly above the rising sun on the reverse of the double eagle, creating the famous ‘With Motto’ variety that circulated until the 1933 gold recall, permanently enshrining this dramatic theological debate in the physical metal of the coin.

Written By

Kacey Corwin

Artisan craft specialist, master maker, and workshop educator at CoinChronicles.xyz. Dedicated to traditional craftsmanship, ceramic science, woodworking, and sustainable studio arts.

Leave a Comment